Voted Best Customer Service Canada
Follow us on Instagram Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Watch us on YouTube Review us on Yelp            
      604.669.6006 | 800.687.9020

Weekly Bottom Line (TD Economics)

The Weekly Bottom Line: TD Economics

October 30, 2009


  • U.S. GDP grows by 3.5% in the third quarter, with consumer spending, residential investment, and exports returning to positive growth.
  • While U.S. new home sales fell and were weaker than expected, the overall housing market continues to trend better, with the Case-Shiller home price index recording its fourth straight month of growth and the inventories of unsold existing homes falling in the Northeast, Midwest, South, and West.
  • The Federal Reserve is unlikely to make any meaningful changes to their statement next week as we still expect them to keep rates low for long.
  • Canadian GDP fell 0.1% in August, dampening prospects for the potency of Canada’s Q3/2009 rebound.
  • Canadian industrial product and raw materials indices declined in September, pointing to continued downward pressure on core consumer prices from cheaper inputs.
  • Employment Insurance beneficiaries declined in August, but likely exhaustion rather than new jobs.
  • Quality-adjusted Teranet-NB house price index buoys from -5.1% Y/Y in July to -3.1% Y/Y in August.
  • Bank of Canada sticks to script that higher dollar means slower recovery, pointing to low rates for longer.
  • On financial regulation, Bank of Canada Governor Carney plugs reform of executive compensation.

US Dollar adn Short Term Rates

this week in the markets

pit and pendulum


economic analysis

The biggest benchmark so far came from the third quarter GDP that showed the U.S. economy grew by an above-average 3.5% pace after four straight quarters of contraction. Auto sales made up a full percentage point of this so we can see the direct impact of the cash-for-clunkers program. But, as the consumer remains the all-important driver for the economy, what we need to see is growth outside of direct stimulus impacts – something we are seeing. Sales of durable goods – autos, dishwashers, and other big ticket purchases that have seen federal and state stimulus efforts – fell by 7% in September and erased the 6% gain seen in August. But spending on services has now grown for four straight months and spending on nondurables – food, clothing, etc. – has grown for four of the last five. The overall pace of growth of consumer spending in those areas is still less than half of normal, but we are seeing progress.

And what of the sector at the center of the storm – housing? After 14 quarters of contraction, home construction finally added to GDP growth in the third quarter, with residential investment up 23%. We discussed these drivers earlier this year ( We are seeing the combined impact of stimulus measures like the first-time homebuyer tax credit and the ongoing decline in the unsold inventory of homes helping to create a bottom in the market. The construction market is still less than half the size it was at the peak, but as with consumer spending, we are seeing progress.

The commercial real estate market has remained a concern for investors, but while it has continued to contract, the -9% pace in Q3 is a far cry from the -44% contraction we saw in the first quarter. There are a few important points to keep in mind. First, our own forecasts for economic recovery assume this sector will shrink into 2011. This is because commercial real estate always lags the residential market, that is normal market dynamics as the Pit and the Pendulum chart here shows. But the need for a correction is based on overvaluations, and while real residential construction had grown 172% over the last 20 years, the nonresidential sector grew by only 35% over the same period.

So, with this sign of recovery, does this mean we are looking for the Dawn of the Fed? Not so fast. The economy is still being fueled by a sugar rush of stimulus. While that’s great for Halloween night, there’s still the headache the next morning to work through as toffee and caramel do not a healthy balanced diet make. And the Fed will have to wait to see signs that the private sector is ready to take on that challenge once again before they risk raising rates. One tell-tale chart here is the strong correlation between changes in the Fed funds rate and changes in capital spending by businesses. After consumers have continued to spend for a little while, and homes have continued to be sold, businesses will start looking to invest, and that is when the Fed will look to tighten rates. Only then, and nothing more.

tell tale chart
Richard Kelly, Senior Economist 416-982-2559




canada econmic chart

Friday’s release of GDP for August, showing a decline of 0.1% in output, was sobering news for Canada’s prospective third quarter performance. While a robust pick-up is nearly assured for the September print, the August GDP data mutes expectations for the speed at which Canada will re-emerge into the black. We do still expect that Canada’s recession ended in the quarter, and anticipate 1% to 1.5% annualized growth. Nonetheless, Canada’s recovery will accelerate over future quarters, with an increasing shift to domestic demand as the source of the boost.

A retreat of production in extractive industries (mining and oil and gas extraction) was a major deadweight on the month, but much of this decline is transient, owing to tem porary mine closures and maintenance work. Manufacturing sector production also slowed, but labour disputes were at the source of diminished output in the primary metals sector.

Despite the August contraction, looking forward, leading indicators for September point to strong monthly growth. Moreover, from the labour force survey, hours-worked were up both in the private-sector broadly and particularly in the goods-producing sectors. As well, manufacturers and wholesalers have now substantially reduced their invento ries – both in absolute terms and relative to the present pace of sales. Surveys of business sentiments express comfort with the present levels of inventories and expectations of heightened sales, pointing to a pick-up in production.

In parsing the monthly GDP print, we should also point out a technical issue associated with the link between the monthly industry-based GDP series and the quarterly na tional accounts GDP series. The latter is computed at “mar ket prices” (the value of GDP paid for by final consumers) while the former is computed at “basic prices” (the value of output produced by firms). 1 Although over time the differ ences wash out, the “market price” measure has seen notably stronger quarterly growth than the “basic price” measure during the past three quarters. This is why the recent weak monthly figured may still produce third quarter growth in the 1% to 1.5% range, representing a downside to the Bank of Canada’s recent 2% forecast.

Bank of Canada communications this week continued to press their anticipation for a sluggish recovery and slow uptake of excess capacity in the economy. Despite the emergence of the U.S. into recovery in the third quarter and a slight moderation of Canada’s dollar this week, the rise of the loonie remains a major drag on exports. The Bank of Canada continues to flag that the dollar’s appreciation will “more then fully offset” other positive developments since July. The slow recovery in exports means protracted economic slack and, consequently, dampened price growth. While viewing exchange rate movements solely through the prism of its price stability mandate, the loonie’s lug points to the Bank leaving interest rates lower for longer. Although its conditional commitment is to hold present rates until the end of Q2/2010, we forecast that the Bank will only begin to hike rates in Q4/2010, owing to the very gradual uptake of slack.

1 The “basic price” measure imbeds taxes and subsidies for labour and capital (e.g., EI premiums and property levies) but excludes taxes on intermediate inputs (e.g., retail sales taxes). For “market prices”, all taxes are imbedded. See: http://www.

leading indicators

Grant Bishop, Economist 416-982-8063


economic releases

U.S. ISM Manufacturing Report - October

Release Date : November 2/09
September Result: 52.6
TD Forecast: 54.0
Consensus: 53.0

After languishing in the midst of its most intense recession for some time, the U.S. manufacturing sector is slowly beginning to gather some positive momentum. The key catalyst for this rebound in manufacturing sector activity has been the recent pick-up in the U.S. economy, while the weak dollar has also played a crucial role in support ing export demand for U.S. manufactured goods. As such, we expect the ISM manufacturing index to rise to 54.0 in October, from the 52.6 print in September. The upward push in the headline index should come mostly from new exports order, while the pick-up in durable goods orders in September (following the sharp drop in August) should bolster the new orders subcomponent. Moreover, with the new orders to inventory spread, a useful proxy for the future direction of manufacturing sector activity, remaining firmly in positive territory, there appears to be further upside sup port for U.S. manufacturing sector activity. In the coming months, we expect the ISM headline index to rise further as U.S. manufacturing sector activity gradually return to life.

Millan Mulraine 416-308-2911

federal funds rate target

FOMC Interest Rate Decision

Release Date: November 4/09

Current Rate: 0.00% to 0.25%

TD Forecast: 0.00% to 0.25%

Consensus: 0.00% to 0.25%

The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) will deliver its next interest rate decision on November 4, and markets will undoubtedly look beyond the actual interest rate announcement, and focus instead on the tone and wording of the actual communiqué. In this regard, we expect the economic outlook to remain largely intact, with the Fed reiterating the improved outlook for the U.S. economy, re flecting in part the encouraging tone in the recent economic reports, and in particular the policy-induced surge in GDP in Q3. The inflation outlook should also remain unchanged, with the Committee noting that it expects inflation to remain “subdued”, on account of the “substantial resource slack” and stable longer-term inflation expectations. We also expect the Fed to reiterate that “the Committee will maintain the target range for the federal funds rate at 0 to 1/4 percent and continues to anticipate that economic conditions are likely to warrant exceptionally low levels of the federal funds rate for an extended period”, and expect the Committee to avoid any mention of exit strategies in the communiqué, though, of course, the discussion on this topic will likely continue at the meeting.

Millan Mulraine 416-308-2911

us labor market

U.S. Nonfarm Payrolls - October

Release Date: November 6/09

September Result: -263K; unemployment rate 9.8%

TD Forecast: -175K; unemployment rate 10.0%

Consensus: -175K; unemployment rate 9.9%

As the U.S. economy continues to slowly dig its way out of the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression, we are likely to see some further improvements in U.S. labour market conditions. Indeed, even though we expect the U.S. economy to continue shedding jobs in the next few months, adding to the 7.2 million jobs that have been already lost the pace of job losses should be considerably less than earlier this year. This much has become evident in the recent weekly jobless claims report and the numerous regional manufacturing sector activity reports. In October, we expect the U.S. economy to shed a further 175K jobs, which will be the slowest pace of job losses in over a year. As has been the case in the past, the losses are likely to be split almost down the middle between the goods-producing and services-producing sectors. In terms of the unemployment rate, we expect the rate of joblessness to rise to 10.0%, which will be the highest rate of unemployment since the early 1980s as the pace of job destruction continues to outpace job creation. In the coming months, the pace of job losses is likely to slow further, with the U.S. economy likely to start creating net new jobs by the beginning of next year.

Millan Mulraine 416-308-2911


upcoming key economic releases

Canadian Employment - October

Release Date : November 6/09

September Result: 30.6K; unemployment rate 8.4%

TD Forecast: -10.0K; unemployment rate 8.6%

Consensus: 10.0K; unemployment rate 8.4%

Even though the Canadian economic recession is likely over, we have been somewhat surprised by the strength of the recent rebound in the labour market in the last two months, when close to 60K jobs were reported to have been added to Canadian payrolls. We believe that this rapid pace of job growth is unsustainable, and expect the performance of the Canadian labour market in October to be far less robust. Indeed, with the strong Canadian dollar continuing to stifle the already beleaguered manufacturing sector and providing a source of significant drag for the Canadian economy more generally, we expect the labour market to give up some of the recent jobs gains, with 10.0K posi tions being lost. The unemployment rate is expected to rise modestly to 8.6%, as previously discouraged workers return to the labour market in the hopes of finding new jobs. In the months ahead, we expect the stabilization in the labour market to continue as the economic recovery takes root.

Millan Mulraine 416-308-2911

recent key economic indicators

upcoming economic indicators



Don Drummond,
Senior Vice President and Chief Economist
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Craig Alexander,
Senior Vice President and Deputy Chief Economist
mailto:This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.


Beata Caranci
Director of Economic Forecasting
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Richard Kelly,
Senior Economist, International
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

James Marple
Economist, United States
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Diana Petramala
Economist, Canada
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Grant Bishop
Economist, Canada
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.


Derek Burleton, Associate Vice President and
Director of Economic Analysis
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Pascal Gauthier
Economist, Regional & Fiscal Canada
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Dina Cover
Economist, Commodites & Industry
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.


Mailing Address

55 King Street West
21st Floor, TD Tower
Toronto, Ontario
M5K 1A2
Fax: (416) 944-5536
mailto: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

This report is provided by TD Economics for customers of TD Bank Financial Group. It is for information purposes only and may not be appropriate for other purposes. The report does not provide material information about the business and affairs of TD Bank Financial Group and the members of TD Economics are not spokespersons for TD Bank Financial Group with respect to its business and affairs. The information contained in this report has been drawn from sources believed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate or complete. The report contains economic analysis and views, including about future economic and financial markets performance. These are based on certain assumptions and other factors, and are subject to inherent risks and uncertainties. The actual outcome may be materially different. The Toronto-Dominion Bank and its affiliates and related entities that comprise TD Bank Financial Group are not liable for any errors or omissions in the information, analysis or views contained in this report, or for any loss or damage suffered.